Directed by Joe and Anthony Russo, US, 2016
First thing’s first, Captain America: Civil War is one of the best two or three Marvel Studios films. It avoids the excesses of the comic book storyline of the same name. Instead it intensely focuses on questions that should be inherent in the superhero genre. What happens to the people in those buildings that get smashed? Or, to blatantly steal a line from a classic graphic novel, who watches the watchmen?
When superheroes fight super-villains, buildings collapse and things blow up. What is rarely addressed is the human cost of that destruction. The concept of superhero collateral damage has been addressed before on film a couple of times, both successfully (The Incredibles (2004)) and unsuccessfully (Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016)). In Captain America: Civil War, the response to this issue sets up the central conflict in the story. The world is grateful, really, but has decided that the Avengers need UN oversight so that the destructive consequences of their operations can be more effectively contained.
That seems reasonable, right? Tony Stark/Iron Man (Robert Downey, Jr.) certainly thinks so. The problem is, what if the powers that be can’t be trusted? What if they are infiltrated, by I don’t know, Hydra? What if they are so bureaucratic that they send what could be their greatest fighting asset on a tour to raise money for war bonds instead of asking him to actually fight? You can see why Steve Rogers/Captain America (Chris Evans) disagrees with Stark.
Somehow, between setting up who’s on what side and actually having a plot, the movie takes the time to effectively introduce not one, but two key Marvel superheroes. The first is T’Challa (Chadwick Boseman), who just happens to be a warrior called the Black Panther. He’s also a king. And a genius. If that’s not enough fun, your friendly neighborhood Spiderman (Tom Holland) joins in on the action too.
Overall, Captain America: Civil War is a great action movie that asks important questions about the cost of security, the need for oversight, and the destructive power of vengeance. If you haven’t already, and the box office receipts tell me that most of you have, go check it out.
You might like Captain America: Civil War if: You are interested in a well executed, smart action film that effectively deconstructs some of the recent blockbuster superhero movies.
You might not like Captain America: Civil War if: You can’t stand watching another superhero movie no matter how good it is.
(c) 2016 D.G. McCabe